Federal watchdog cracks down on Bank of America but ‘junk fees’ aren’t going anywhere, expert says — it’s a ‘game of whack-a-mole’

Junk charges are extra, usually hidden, prices that may come from a variety of lenders. They aren’t usually included within the preliminary value of a transaction however are tacked on on the time of cost.

“Shoppers are encountering these ‘shock’ prices extra usually than they may anticipate, in every little thing from live performance ticket surcharges to airline seat choice charges, bank card late charges, financial institution overdraft charges, resort resort charges and extra,” in response to Ted Rossman, senior trade analyst at Bankrate.

But even when these charges have been capped and even banned totally, it is unlikely that customers would get monetary savings because of this, he stated.

“Overdraft charges are a great instance of a ‘recreation of whack-a-mole’ in terms of charges,” Rossman stated.

When many monetary establishments lowered their overdraft and non-sufficient funds charges or eradicated them altogether, the common overdraft charge fell whereas ATM surcharges jumped to a report excessive, Bankrate discovered.

Most often, even with extra transparency, the all-in value to shoppers would doubtless stay the identical, in response to Rossman.

President Joe Biden has stated his administration would crack down on junk charges — together with these from banks, in addition to motels, airways and different service suppliers.

“Junk charges might not matter to the very rich, however they matter to most other people in properties just like the one I grew up in, like a lot of you probably did,” Biden stated in his State of the Union handle earlier this yr. “They add as much as tons of of {dollars} a month.”

Biden additionally referred to as on Congress to go the Junk Price Prevention Act, which can scale back sudden prices, resembling airline reserving charges; service charges for live performance tickets; early termination charges for TV, cellphone and web providers; “resort charges” at motels; and “extreme” bank card late charges.

Final yr, the CFPB stated it was scrutinizing sure charges that catch prospects abruptly — and are “doubtless unfair and illegal,” in response to the company.

The buyer watchdog proposed a new rule prohibiting banks from charging shock overdraft charges on debit transactions and decreasing typical late charges from roughly $30 to $8, saving shoppers as a lot as $9 billion a yr, in response to the White Home.

“Regardless of latest progress in addressing overdraft charges, the job is way from full,” Nadine Chabrier, the Middle for Accountable Lending’s senior coverage counsel, stated in a press release.

“The Client Monetary Safety Bureau took a giant step by banning shock overdraft charges,” she stated. “We’re inspired that the buyer bureau introduced it is going to take extra steps, and we urge the bureau to position robust limits on the dimensions and frequency of those charges.”

Greater than 1 / 4 of checking account holders, or 27%, are often hit with charges, which may add as much as a mean of $24 per 30 days, or $288 per yr, in response to a one other survey from Bankrate. 

The typical overdraft charge prices $29.80, Bankrate’s analysis discovered, whereas the common nonsufficient funds charge is $26.58.

Some banking curiosity teams countered that choices resembling overdraft safety present a much-needed security internet.

“The president’s use of the time period ‘junk charge’ is overly broad and ignores the wants of low-income and middle-income shoppers who depend upon these providers to resolve short-term monetary difficulties,” Jim Nussle, president and CEO of the Credit score Union Nationwide Affiliation, stated in a press release.

“It doesn’t contemplate the prices concerned in offering wanted monetary providers that customers depend upon.”

With out the choice of overdraft safety, “individuals are extra more likely to flip to predatory lenders, hurting the identical individuals the administration seeks to assist,” Nussle stated.

Subscribe to CNBC on YouTube.