Distress Investing: A Tale of Two Case Studies

With recession forecasted in lots of economies this yr or subsequent, distressed conditions will likely be an necessary supply of offers for potential traders.

However what is going to matter is whether or not the targets are completely impaired or will be rotated. Two real-life situations from the debt bubble of the early aughts and the following credit score crunch present useful steering.

Cyclical Volatility, or Dislocation

The UK funding agency Candover purchased the hygienic merchandise producer Ontex for €1 billion, or 8.1 instances EBITDA, in 2002. The debt bundle, composed of bog-standard senior and mezzanine loans, totaled 6 instances earnings.

Regardless of sturdy financial development, Ontex’s EBITDA margin dropped from 17% to 12% inside three years due largely to rising oil costs. Oil is a key ingredient of the absorbent powder in Ontex’s diapers, and the corporate couldn’t cross the prices onto clients as a result of their merchandise are distributed by Walmart, Tesco, and different value setters with oligopolistic positions. Unable to ship on to shoppers, and as a private-label producer with no dominant model, Ontex is a price-taker.

However this wasn’t a brand new growth. Prior to now, Ontex’s profitability had slumped at any time when oil costs spiked. Nonetheless, extreme leverage didn’t make Ontex a nasty funding. Moderately, its debt bundle had a inflexible construction with a set compensation schedule and strict curiosity margins when market cyclicality demanded extra agile lending phrases.

When TPG and Goldman Sachs bought Ontex from Candover in 2010, covenant-light — cov-lite — loans had grow to be plain-vanilla devices that gave debtors the pliability to adapt to such financial dislocation. That was what Ontex wanted. As crude oil costs rose greater than 160% between early 2016 and late 2018, its EBITDA margins slipped from 12.5% to 10.2%.

Structural Change, or Disruption

However there’s one other type of misery situation the place market shifts are extra intensive.

The non-public fairness (PE) agency Terra Firma executed a leveraged buyout (LBO) of the storied report label EMI Music, valued at £4.2 billion, in 2007. Not like Ontex’s debt construction, EMI’s featured all of the methods within the PE toolkit, together with a gracious cov-lite bundle with limitless rights to fairness cures and ample EBITDA changes. But the deal proved disastrous.

The web revolution had shaken up the recording trade, and for years EMI had struggled to adapt. To show EMI’s fortunes round, Terra Firma deliberate to lift capital within the bond markets and safe it towards the recurring money flows of EMI’s music catalogs. It additionally hoped to revive margins by chopping the workforce, outsourcing some actions, renegotiating artist contracts, rationalizing the property portfolio, and shrinking expense accounts. Terra Firma likewise had its eye on new income streams — concert events, on-line providers, merchandising, and artist administration — and sought to onboard new tech expertise to implement the digital transition.

But regardless of a number of fairness cures, EMI’s sole lender, Citi, took it over in 2011 and swiftly bought it off piecemeal. EMI, it turned out, was not experiencing a short dislocation however a everlasting disruption. As a consequence of on-line piracy, US compact disc (CD) shipments had collapsed by two-fifths between 1999 and 2007. Within the fiscal quarter previous the buyout, EMI CD gross sales had fallen by 20%. Paying over 18 instances trailing EBITDA for such a enterprise proved unwise.

Including leverage to a enterprise dealing with such extreme challenges wasn’t advisable. EMI’s internet debt-to-EBITDA ratio remained above 8 all through the LBO interval. The turnaround technique by no means improved profitability sufficient to maintain up with the steepening debt commitments.

The Dangers Pyramid

EMI’s expertise exhibits how important execution threat doesn’t combine effectively with leverage amid a significant restructuring. Price cuts, asset disposals, contract renegotiations, refinancing, securitizations, and different typical strategic and working instruments are not any match for disruptive innovation.

That’s why dislocation can’t be confused with disruption. The previous is short-term and cyclical — it’s manageable, even when it’s recurrent by nature. Disruption, against this, is everlasting and structural; for a lot of companies, it’s a terminal menace. Whereas dislocation requires adaptation and will be tackled by progressively altering a agency’s technique, disruption requires reinvention, wherein case a agency should reengineer its operations. In such a elementary situation, the intensive use of debt is a really unhealthy concept.

The Dangers Pyramid under visualizes this dilemma: Leverage sits atop many different threat classes. Firms have little room for monetary threat — i.e., debt — when dealing with market, operational, and strategic headwinds. Underneath the burden of a lot uncertainty, extra leverage can crush any company borrower.

Dangers Pyramid Construction

The Nice Glut

The unprecedented financial stimulus within the aftermath of the worldwide monetary disaster (GFC) and throughout the pandemic ought to supply fertile floor for misery investing within the years forward. Extra capital is incessantly misallocated and results in wasteful and ill-advised investments. It may well kill returns.

Debt-bloated buyouts and overcapitalized start-ups are plentiful, however due to capital accumulation — $12 trillion of property, together with $3 trillion in dry powder — non-public markets could take a very long time to regulate. Following its March 2000 peak, the NASDAQ didn’t hit backside till October 2002, and lots of dot-coms had been nonetheless reeling when the GFC broke out. As we speak’s non-public market shakeout could entail a equally prolonged wait. PE and enterprise capital (VC) corporations would favor to carry onto impaired property and hold incomes charges reasonably than acknowledge the true state of their portfolios. But with current financial institution collapses, the bridge financing that start-ups must postpone any down spherical could dry up.

With their avid use of leverage, monetary sponsors can nonetheless handle draw back dangers by negotiating looser mortgage agreements and massaging numbers. An excessive amount of debt, nevertheless, can depart debtors in a zombie state and make it more durable for misery traders to step in. They may have to attend it out like Citi did amid EMI’s inescapable disintegration within the wake of the GFC.

Coping with Market Fracture

The financialization of the markets raises a broader query: Does the rising debt overhang signify short-term turbulence or a extra radical discontinuity of contemporary economies?

The price of a stretched stability sheet varies: Companies minimize investments; credit score downgrades drag down inventory returns; company executives search different employment; staff grow to be uncooperative; suppliers drive more durable cost phrases; shoppers change to extra dependable service suppliers; lenders increase the price of debt or minimize off entry to credit score altogether.

Even when endemic overleverage doesn’t result in widespread financial destruction, dislocation-prone industries may ultimately grow to be extra completely impaired. As we speak’s elevated inflation, as an example, may very well be thought-about only a minor hurdle for Ontex: As oil costs rose from lower than $0 per barrel in 2020 to greater than $120 two years later, the corporate’s EBITDA margins tumbled from 11.2% in 2020 to five.5% final yr. Leverage now exceeds 6 instances earnings, as within the days of the Candover LBO 20 years in the past, when EBITDA margin stood at 17%.

However the COVID-19 pandemic has provoked demographic instability that would have far deeper ramifications for corporations like Ontex, which serves each the younger and the aged by promoting diapers and incontinence merchandise. Extra mortality has jumped in Europe and the USA. This development could also be short-lived, however it follows stalling life expectancy in the USA, the European Union, and England and Wales. The advantages of improved sanitation and public well being have, maybe momentarily, reached their limits.

The pandemic additionally catalyzed one other demographic evolution. Moderately than an anticipated COVID-19 child growth, lockdowns could have contributed to a “child bust.” Whereas post-COVID-19 financial stimulus helped beginning charges rebound to pre-pandemic ranges, demographic challenges stay. In struggling economies like Japan, Spain, and Italy, declining fertility charges have lengthy been the norm. But when shifting beginning charges and flatlining life expectancy grow to be additional entrenched, they’d not signify mere dislocations, like periodic oil value spikes, however extra acute market fractures affecting long-term demand for hygienic merchandise.

The ramifications would clearly lengthen far past anybody firm or sector. Therein lies the difficulty with investing. Markets are dynamic: Macroeconomic turbulence and sociodemographic transitions can remodel worth performs into distressed property.

In the event you preferred this publish, don’t neglect to subscribe to the Enterprising Investor.

All posts are the opinion of the writer(s). As such, they shouldn’t be construed as funding recommendation, nor do the opinions expressed essentially replicate the views of CFA Institute or the writer’s employer.

Picture credit score: ©Getty Pictures / SDI Productions

Skilled Studying for CFA Institute Members

CFA Institute members are empowered to self-determine and self-report skilled studying (PL) credit earned, together with content material on Enterprising Investor. Members can report credit simply utilizing their on-line PL tracker.

Sebastien Canderle

Sebastien Canderle is a personal capital advisor. He has labored as an funding government for a number of fund managers. He’s the writer of a number of books, together with The Debt Entice and The Good, the Dangerous and the Ugly of Personal Fairness. Canderle additionally lectures on different investments at enterprise faculties. He’s a fellow of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales and holds an MBA from The Wharton Faculty.